93019 Near Miss Crossing Inexperience
In Extremis
- English Channel. Day Time. Wind SE 2/3. Vis. 3 to 4 miles.
- Report No. 93019.
Own ship, a 265 m long bulk carrier and draft of 14.8 m, was steering 0750 T at 12.5 knots in the "stream" of traffic heading towards the Dover Strait TSS. Target was detected on the port bow on a course of 2300 T and making 17/18 knots. The CPA according to the ARPA was 0.1 miles. When the ship came into sight she could easily be identified as a large container ship belonging to a well known company. At two miles range there was no sign of an alteration from her. I sounded six short blasts with no response. I called on VHF Channel 16 identifying the target by the company name and requesting that she alter course to starboard, no reply was received. At very close range the target began to heel and she turned to PORT. She passed about 2.5 cables ahead (distance from my bridge) still heeling, carried on about half a mile, then steadied and resumed her previous course. I called again on the VHF and a young voice (of probably Asiatic origin, i.e. not a deep sea pilot) said that he had got confused and was now resuming course.
My ship takes a long time to alter course at this draft and speed and there was no point in altering in extremis. It was therefore a most "uncomfortable" situation to have to watch the scene unfold and be almost powerless to avoid the consequences. I was under the impression that this company's ships carried a sea pilot, and I can only assume that if this was the case, the pilot had left the bridge when the ship had cleared the Dover Strait TSS. The ship had then altered course to 2300 T to head for Cherbourg, either for cargo or to disembark the pilot.
As we passed on up the Channel I noticed several ships which altered to the south west once they had passed the Greenwich buoy. One could not wait that long and cut across the separation zone and the north east lane on a course of south west. There would appear to be an argument for continuing the separation scheme further to the west. The traffic is still heavy between here and the TSS off the Casquets and there is considerable crossing traffic. There is always a lot of fishing activity, this always causes anxiety due to the unpredictable manoeuvres the fishing boats indulge in, and the fact that they are more difficult to see in moderate or poor visibility.
Extending the Dover Strait TSS further down the channel to join with the Casquets scheme would have helped in this case and the idea is worth considering. It may, however, just transfer the problems further west, particularly for traffic coming from the west.